Some University of Melbourne students feel that the ten residential colleges dominate university life, whereas some know nothing about them. One commonality between these students: they consistently dislike the University’s colleges.
Some University of Melbourne students feel that the ten residential colleges dominate university life, whereas some know nothing about them. One commonality between these students: they consistently dislike the University’s colleges.
Even former college students feel more negatively towards UniMelb colleges than their inter-university alternatives, according to Farrago survey data.
Both subsets of students cite entitlement and discrimination as areas of critique in a questionnaire distributed to 109 UniMelb students. Many students consider the colleges “annoying”, “pretentious” and “built for the wealthy to stay in bubbles for as long as possible”.
The University’s website highlights the “vibrant, close-knit community of like-minded students” within colleges. However, in practice, these are revealed to be exclusive circles which emit senses of superiority, if not deliberately, to other students at the University.
While this is often seen by students at an interpersonal level, these attitudes are cultivated within the foundations of college institutions. College events are often internal, offering valuable opportunities to their students, such as additional tutorials or access to political candidates.
Colleges also run their own Welcome Weeks, often clashing with University organised events, discouraging college students from making friends externally.
Such opportunities are funded by an annual average of $39,238 per student in fees.
While the survey found that many students consider this an unreasonable amount of money, UniMelb emphasises accessibility through the availability of scholarships. This includes the Naarm Scholarship, which can meet $29,500 of the cost of University owned colleges’: International House or Wilam Hall.
“Our colleges and the University offer a variety of scholarships to support students in meeting living and relocation costs,” said a University of Melbourne spokesperson.
Other colleges offer scholarships, however, a limited amount of their budget is dedicated towards them. Trinity College redirects less than 3.5 per cent of income to scholarships—less than the amount they receive from donations and bequests.
This is also less than the amount of income tax they would pay without the exemption they receive as registered charities under the Australian Charities and Not for Profit Commission.
According to their charity profiles, UniMelb’s colleges benefit “those aged 15 to under 65, females, males, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, financially disadvantaged people, overseas communities or charities, and people in rural/regional/remote communities”.
Unlike many charities, every college made a significant profit in the last financial year, which is permitted as long as it is reinvested in their activities. Trinity College made a profit of $17 million in 2025, compared to $2.8 million provided as scholarships that same year.
Farrago reached out to Trinity College for comment on their intentions with this profit but have not received a response.
In their financial success and classification as charities, UniMelb’s colleges share a stark resemblance with many others, such as the University of Sydney’s (USyd). However, they diverge in their social success, evading the Abolish the Colleges movement which has plagued USyd’s colleges since the release of the Red Zone Report in 2018.
The report details experiences of sexual harassment and hazing in colleges across Australia. In Sydney, this prompted outrage, with the City of Sydney Council moving a motion to abolish USyd’s colleges on 25 November 2024. This motion was withdrawn a mere ten minutes later.
Throughout October 2026, USyd’s student newspaper, Honi Soit, published several articles reporting on accounts of sexual assault in USyd colleges. In response, USyd lodged a complaint with the Student Representative Council's Publications Committee alleging inaccurate reporting. The Committee found no flaws.
“The willingness of [USyd] to immediately dispute the claims without a proper investigation speaks volumes regarding the seriousness of which USyd handles these events [...] I will never engage in college life because of this,”said USyd student, Pyper Marchant.
While the Red Zone Report makes explicit reference to the conduct of UniMelb colleges, highlighting various alleged rapes that have taken place at colleges, no such outcry has taken place in Melbourne.
This year, anonymous writers have revealed the contemporary nature of these issues through a Reddit post made about Janet Clarke Hall and an article written in the International House yearbook.
In the now deleted Reddit post, the user alleged that “many of the women living at college have also experienced harassment, bullying or unwanted uncomfortable interactions with other students here, and are not satisfied with how the administration has handled formal complaints which have been issued.”


International House yearbook (Satadal)’s article, “What is IH’s Problem?”
Currently, the NSW Greens have committed to bring forth a bill which would convert USyd’s colleges into affordable housing. The Victorian Greens have not made any similar promises, despite their common focus on affordable housing. Farrago has reached out to the Victorian Greens for comment but has not received a response.
While survey data shows that college students find value in their experiences at college, mission statements are trailing behind actions as non-college students feel excluded and separated within the university environment.
Image source: Ormond College